Skip to content

Judge Reyes rebukes DOJ in Potomac golf course hearing

newsNov 13, 2026282,458

In a Friday hearing over the planned closure and renovation of the East Potomac Park golf course, U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes sharply questioned Justice Department lawyers and ordered DOJ to file an unredacted version of the submission to the National Capital Planning Commission naming who worked on the proposal by 5 p.m. DOJ had argued those names should remain sealed. Reyes repeatedly criticized the department’s answers, rejecting a DOJ invocation of a “presumption of regularity” and asking, “Do you think someone went to vote saying I want a President who can redo the golf courses in DC?” The judge warned that if she finds documents were destroyed she will move for sanctions or contempt “in less than a zepto-second.” Commenters and reporters at the hearing described DOJ counsel as evasive and unprepared, and some singled out DOJ attorney Gustafson for what they called obfuscation and poor readiness. The court’s order for the unredacted filing and Reyes’s destruction warning set up a fast follow-up: the government must produce the named document by 5 p.m. and faces rapid sanctions proceedings if records are missing or destroyed.

Chris Geidner
@chrisgeidner.bsky.social

NEW: Judge Reyes orders DOJ to file an unredacted version of this document — detailing who worked on the East Potomac Golf Course submission to the National Capital Planning Commission — by 5p today. DOJ had argued it should be able to keep the names under seal.

After a diligent inquiry, the Government has identified the following individuals who drafted, edited, or provided input - or how the Government has defined "participated in preparing"
- on the draft of the NCPC submission that was provided to the National Capital Planning
Commission:
'As a matter of factual clarification, the NCPC submission is not the rendering which is docketed at ECE No. 1l1-1. The NCPC submission, referred to in the notice (ECt No. 111) and provided to the Plaintiffs is a different document.
1
Case 1:26-cv-00477-ACR Document 131-1
Filed 11/03/26
Page 2 of 4
17185d ago