Zelensky says US envoys floated ceding Donbas for NATO membership
Zelenskyy confirms US negotiators asked Ukraine to withdraw from Donbas in exchange for NATO membership, despite Rubio privately telling European counterparts that Ukrainian membership is unrealistic.
They baited and switched. Give up the fortified line and get a membership Rubio already calls unrealistic in private. Kyiv is asked to pay upfront for something Washington has no plan to deliver.
Zelensky would be a fool to trust the US at this time. I don't think he's a fool.
The bastards…dangling an impossible choice in front of Zelenskyy. 😢 And in the end, the US would betray Ukraine anyway.
How about Russia withdraw to the Moscow suburbs and we'll make a demilitarized zone...
He should tell USA to fuck off.
Ukraine should have to make zero concessions and should get NATO membership years ago. Russia should not invade other countries.
Rubio and the US delegation cannot be trusted. I believe the Europeans see this, I know Zelenskyy is not falling for the deception!
This is a heck of thing to ask for - what country would do this? In Canada, would we hand over B.C. or New Brunswick? Shameful ask. Simply shameful.
Russia does not determine if Ukraine joins NATO. NATO does. Unless the US is bargaining on behalf of Russia, who is NOT a member of NATO. 🤷
Zelenskyy knows more than anyone what a bunch of crooks these fucking REPUBLICANS are!
Out and out extortion. And then they’ll renege on NATO membership. Zelenskyy won’t go for that; he’s no dummy.
Yeah right, twelve years in and you still haven’t taken all of the Donbas. NATO has never attacked Russia, yet you invaded your neighbour and committed the most appalling atrocities while somehow still failing to achieve the goals you set out for invading in the first place.
Now your best hope rests with a lame-duck US president and two of his pretend diplomats. Hardly a position of strength to be making demands from. 🤔
There can be no "negotiated" peace with Russia, even if the US sent real diplomats instead of crooked corruptocrats. Why? Because Russia never HONOURS its agreements. Russia cannot be trusted. It must be broken - militarily; economically; & politically. Trump has damaged the US & the western world
Why are American tax dollars paying these guys to be spokesmen for Putin? Let him pay his own spokesmen.
They haven't taken Donbas, but they did take the White House.
Russia demands? A second tier nation committing war crimes does not demand anything. It deserves to be sanctioned, ostracized, and isolated until it behaves properly and stops its aggression.
As I said before. Nato could comply as soon as russia retreats to Mongolia.
The Donbas thing is the tell. Moscow wanted the whole country in days, got pushed off Kyiv, then rebranded the fallback as the original plan. Twelve years in and the second-largest army in the world is still grinding over the same towns, and the bill is enormous.
BREAKING NEWS: losing military demands superior force retreat before it’s too late.
Exactly right. We trust words coming from the kremlin as if they nevdr lied in their memorandums, never lied about troop deaths, never lied about taking land, and never lied daily. Their words are not used to convey facts or sense. just ambitions.
The Kushner/Witkoff gambit to Ukraine: you can become a NATO member if you surrender 25% of your territory to the Kremlin... and by the way, we'll dissolve NATO as soon as you do. www.ft.com/content/2431...
why are these failed “business” conmen even allowed to be speaking to anyone on behalf of the U.S. ever let alone about Ukraine/Europe???
Surrender 25% now and get a membership card to an alliance that dissolves on delivery, a receipt. The whole offer exists to give Moscow a veto over Ukraine's alliances while presenting that veto as peace.
Didn't Ukraine just do this with their nuclear weapons a few decades ago and now they're here, experiencing exactly what was promised would never be allowed to happen? That's a deal that makes for more war in a short time.
Don’t do what Kushner / Witkoff suggest . That’s a trap.
The Trump administration is not an honest broker when Russia has an interest. Trump is a Russian agent who, despite his brave talk, does not dare displease Putin.
Why even talk to liars out to fuck you?
🇺🇦Fool me twice? After having been talked by the then US government into giving up its nukes in exchange for ‘security guarantees’ that later proved worthless, Ukraine would be insane to consider such a deal…but Zelenskyy can probably not say that out loud for diplomatic reasons & needs to play along
I would never enter into ANY deal with The Mango Mussolini. Period. Ever.
“.. Zelenskyy said US peace envoys asked whether Ukraine would be willing to give up the Donbas region in the nation’s east to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, signaling a potential shift in Washington’s negotiating tactics.” @bloomberg.com 🇺🇦 www.bloomberg.com/news/article...
U.S. can't be trusted to uphold their part of the deal.
Two reminders: TrumpCo already broke our word in the Budapest Memorandum, where we pledged not to extort Ukraine, and as Zelenskyy explained back in 2022, giving up land and liberty is against Ukraine’s very constitution—upon which he swore his oath of office:
What good is that, Trump wouldn’t support defending a NATO ally….
Don’t trust them president Zelensky!
What the hell? That's the whole reason Putin said he sarted the war....I think that we need negotiators with big fffing bombs...That is the only thing Putin respects.
Putin will never be satisfied with JUST Donbas. He wants ALL of Ukraine for his new Russian empire. Trump can't be trusted, no matter how many pieces of paper he signs. He has already shown that he is perfectly willing to ignore agreements that he himself signed. Besides, Trump works for Putin.
And then Trump leaves NATO.
getting Ukraine into NATO is ultimately a good way to keep Russia thinking twice about further shenanigans splitting Donbas ensures further shenanigans, so I think the ultimate result of a Donbas-for-NATO deal is that inevitably Article 5 gets triggered more amateur hour ideas
BREAKING: US negotiators have touted the idea of Ukraine withdrawing its remaining forces from the eastern Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership, Ukrainian President Zelensky says. Kyiv has long sought membership in NATO as a condition of any peace deal to deter future threats.
How about NATO membership and they give up nothing.
While the Trump regime, aka Putin's puppet, is working to destroy NATO from the inside.
Interestingly, those same negotiators and Putin are trying to break up NATO. I hope Zelenskyy doesn’t buy it. The next US President can help him get into NATO and help him finish this war. If Putin had a chance in hell of winning, he wouldn’t be asking him to depart E. Donbas, he would just take it.
I think this may be a trap
As much as I want the Ukrainian people safety and security, fuck that. Fuck Russia, fuck tRump and fuck Kkkushner. Slava Ukraine ✊
Interesting….although US is now a totally unreliable NATO member, so it’s basically just Europe saying they will fight the Russians, which they should do anyway.
Fuck #Kushner #Zelenskyy #Boycott #X Boycott #ElonMusk Boycott #SpaceX Boycott #Tesla #SlavaZelenskyy #SlavaUkrainii #Putin'sWar #NAFO
This "deal" is a character check. I would personally urge President Zelensky to reject it. trumps is actively working to withdraw from NATO which would effectively destroy it.
Putin will never accept that.
Melenchon is lying again. He keeps insisting Zelensky proposed a referendum *in* Donbas to see if people there want Russia or Ukraine when in reality Zelensky says he is constitutionally bound to call a Ukraine-wide referendum *on* whether Ukrainians agree to withdraw from Donbas as a concession.
He could not be so utterly stupid as to not see the difference between these two things, which has been explained repeatedly by French media and big social media accounts so he must be lying. No one should ever vote for this man.
Even if a referendum was held in the Donbas it would be totally interfered with by Russia and if it wasn’t Russia wouldn’t respect the outcome so what’s the point.
The swap matters. A Donbas-only plebiscite under Russian guns is a land grab with a ballot box, while a Ukraine-wide vote on a constitutional concession is Kyiv making a binding commitment to the Ukrainian people. Melenchon is laundering the first as the second.
For some reason, the French are still seeing something in him, that doesn't exist. He is a closet imperialist at heart. Look objectively, scratch the veneer and you will see Trump. Same anger, same disregard for facts, same contempt for the common people, same disregard for democracy.
Melenchon is a hopeless cause. Like "Die Linke" in Germany a Pro-Fascist movement, supporting Russia doing their genocide in Ukraine undisturbed. Seeing the polls in Germany and France dark clouds are rising over Europe. I hope the US will be there to take the torch again by then.
Zelensky says Ukraine will neither adopt constitutional neutrality nor recognize Russian sovereignty over occupied territories. The US has asked whether Kyiv would leave Donbas in exchange for NATO access. Zelensky is open to public discussion if security and reconstruction guarantees are provided.
Ad nauseam: it is not up to the US to give away NATO memberships like a bone to a dog. As to guarantees, the US is no longer trustworthy and no longer a friend. They are in Putain’s pocket.
No one can trust trump or putin. As long as they are alive, Ukraine must not make any peace agreement with them. No appeasing traitors or dictators. Ukraine MUST maintain it's 1992 borders which includes CRIMEA! This war will not end in 2027. Prepare for more starshield outages. This is THEIR plan.
In this case the US is a couple of real estate brokers and I wouldn't trust them with a wooden nickel.
The US are a disgrace, working with putin to force russia to concede more, yet russia still occupies crimea. Fuck russia. Europe should stand behind ukraine at every level. Arm zelensky to the teeth and let him nail putin and finish the job. The end.
Good...mentioning joining NATO is now on the table. Here are Ukraines terms....Russia leaves all occupied territories and then Ukraine joins NATO. This ensures Russia is safe (NATO is a defence alliance) and Europe is secure. Simple.
I didn’t think ruzzia wanted NATO near its borders. So it doesn’t make sense!
US has floated Ukraine ceding Donbas for Nato membership, Zelensky says And I think Zelensky should float US ceding New Mexico to Mexico and sod it.. why not Texas too 🤷♂️
100%. Not often JHB gets it right but Tice was on TalkTV defending Donald Trump’s approach to ending the war. Took her about 30 seconds to find the problem with his argument. She asked which part of Britain he would be prepared to surrender if we were invaded.
US can just float away into the Gulf of Mexico or sink into lake Ottawa .Ukraine deserve NATO membership for their bravery not on trumps say so
Cede Hawaii to Japan - like Russia, they couldn’t take it militarily-so why not give it to them for free!
Cede Alaska to Russia as well. MAGA: just there for the money.
The whole bogus negotiation is a ploy to give Putin a breathing space to recover his forces and tRump is front and centre promoting it. They don't give Nobel prizes to those who side with the aggressor.
And how did I miss Trump having the say over who joins NATO, when and on what conditions? Thought he no longer liked NATO anyway. Idiotic suggestion - try giving Putin Alaska instead .
US has floated Ukraine ceding Donbas for Nato membership, Zelensky says share.google/vZxDjfYSHca9... Ukraine should give up NOTHING‼️ Fuck Trump Fuck Kushner
Why is the U.S. even IN this discussion?! Our 🤡-in-chief has proven his loyalty to Putin, Musk is determining our foreign policy with his tax-subsidized tech, and the 🤡🤡 civilian negotiators (Kushner and Witkoff) are on their knees for Putin.
Hell no. RU invaded Crimea right after the Olympics thanks to prepositioning troops under cover of Olympic security (refused to allow normal int'l shared Olympic security after Munich). RU is the aggressor. Hand them their asses, not any territory. 👹🔥
If Putin has put NATO membership on the table it either means he’s desperate to end the conflict and this is how he intends to save face, or he doesn’t expect NATO to survive much longer.
Ukraine should not have to “bargain” to join NATO and they should not have to give up anything. The U.S. is supposed to be supporting Ukraine NOT Russia. What the actual f*ck!?
Ukraine should give up nothing. Absolutely 💯. Nothing! Russia needs to give up and pay for what they have done.
Russia is demanding that NATO stop expanding. This US ‘deal’ sounds like (at best) incompetent double speak or (at worst) setting a trap.
‼️ Zelenskyy: US proposes NATO membership in exchange for Donbas withdrawal for the first time
NATO membership is worthless when the USA is allied with Russia. A new security structure is needed without the yanks. The JEF is a blue print that can be expanded and CANZUK can also be incorporated. No-one trusts the yanks
🚨IT’S A TRAP🚨 Ukraine cannot trust compromised USA! 1. USA cannot offer NATO membership unilaterall 2. Ukraine’s sovereign borders are constitutionally immutable 3. An affirmative response by Ukraine establishes a precedent for modifying its sovereign borders, establishing it is negotiable.
NEVER TRUST TRUMP OR PUTIN!
Trump wants to sign Ukraine up to an alliance he wants the US to leave, in negotiations he excluded Europe from while negotiating with 2 countries that didn't adhere to the Budapest agreement protecting the third. I didn't think he could reach news levels of stupid, but he's proved me wrong.
It’s a false promise NATO membership cannot be promised by one NATO country, all must agree
And tomorrow the US proposes something different 🤡
* BREAKING * Zelenskyy says he will hold a referendum if Ukraine is promised NATO membership in exchange for giving up ALL of Donbas. Ukraine's president said the US has raised this possibility for the first time at the recent talks.
Canada will never allow Russia a "cordon sanitaire." PM Mark Carney responds to Putin's reported demands of NATO being forced into all sorts of concessions.
As far as I've recently learned, there have been polls on similar topics, and the Ukrainian public has spoken out against such "agreements" by an overwhelming majority. #Ukraine
I hope, the translation is flawed and Ukraine is part of NATO, before giving up all of Donbas. Instead of a promised membership...
Going to need more than a promise. Remember the Budapest Memorandum.
The problem is that the White House is completely unreliable. The words of Trump, Vance and Rubio aren't worth a single bit more than Putin's.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said that the United States proposed Ukraine cede land to Russia in exchange for joining NATO
How about we help them remove the invaders and then they join NATO?
Even if the Ukrainians felt this was the best outcome it could get, before the ink was dry on conceding Donbas, the trump administration would renège on the NATO membership offer
How did appeasement of crazy dictators work out in the past? Oh yeah, millions dead.
Ukraine begrudgingly accepts this one-sided deal and then Trump takes the US out of NATO leaving Ukraine with nothing.
I am ashamed that this country’s so-called leaders have capitulated to Putin likely in exchange for filthy lucre. Such a craven US proposal must be rejected as it won’t bring peace. Also, it’s time for Russia to fix its Putin problem.
And what did NATO say to this?
Even if Ukraine agreed to cede territory (which would also go against its own Constitution as of now), what guarantee would there be that the US promise of NATO membership would hold? Why should anyone trust an administration which has consistently undermined Kyiv and played into Moscow's hands?
Europe's collective response to this drivel should be: Ukraine will accept such a deal on the condition that the United States shows the way by ceding Alaska back to Russia (pre-1867), Hawaii back to the Hawaiians (pre-1898), New Mexico nack to Mexico (pre-1848) and so on.
Since Trump has been clear that the US no longer considers itself bound by Article 5, what would be the point?
The first operation of any new EU Army should be the liberation of our American friends.
Let us say that Ukraine were even able to accept such an imposition, what guarantee is there that the US, under this administration, would honour its NATO obligations if not withdraw from NATO entirely as a next step? Part of the Trump problem is that the US has become self-defeatingly unreliable.
Trump Admin 2.0 doesn't even believe in the existence of NATO. The bad faith, it is never ending.
People who defend Chamberlain argue he had to concede because Britain and France weren’t in a position to fight Germany. The position can be disputed but at least Britain and France declared war on Germany when Poland was invaded the next year. Trump would never uphold his side of the bargain.
America is no longer an ally under Donald Trump #PutinsPuppet
The fact that the US even put this on the table shows that they have no idea why Russia started this war or what Putin wants from it. It's been two years of completely wasted diplomatic efforts
😡 The US is so completely owned by Russia, it would almost be laughable if it wasn't so serious. Fuck off.
The U.S. has floated the idea of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for withdrawing from its eastern Donbas region as part of negotiations to end the war, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said yesterday.
Don't believe the Trump administration, signed all the American people.
The Trump mafia is still wanting Ukraine to give up hundreds of thousands more of its citizens to fascist Russia. Delusional.
I wouldn't trust us, and Russia wouldn't agree to Ukraine joining NATO.
Yeah, and at the same time rUsSiA suggested Finland should leave NATO. The logic on itsself: they took part of your country. Give it to them and there might be the option we protect you when in the future they try to take more. Remind me again what happened with Crimea?
How about U.S. giving Alaska to Russia and Florida to Cuba?
Didn't Russia invade Ukraine to stop NATO expansion? Or was it to "denazify" Ukraine? Or protect Donbas? Hard to keep track of the changing excuses. And now the US proposes giving Russia Ukrainian land in exchange for Ukraine joining NATO? How does that make any sense?
This is American bullshit. For starters, Russia doesn't accept that NATO should have any members in central and eastern Europe, and Scandinavia, in what it considers to be the Russian Empire's sphere of influence. Russia under Putin and the siloviki will never accept Ukraine joining NATO.
Sure, just like the deal we gave Ukraine when they gave up nuclear weapons. Don’t do it, Zelenskyy!! We’re lying to you!