Pop‑Tarts flavor debate
A Pop-Tarts flavor debate centers on which varieties are best and worst, with unfrosted versions prompting defenders WHO dislike frosting texture and wild-berry entries drawing frequent complaints about taste. S'mores and a 'Mystery Flavored' everything-bagel variant are repeatedly named among the worst, and many say savory Pop-Tarts are gross on principle. Kellogg now lists Protein Pop-Tarts on its website, which has raised concerns from shoppers worried about stevia-like aftertastes. This matters because Pop-Tarts relies on nostalgia and limited-edition experiments, so bad flavors can alienate longtime buyers and make future product launches riskier.
What's the worst flavor Pop-Tart you've ever had? (Also, yes ha ha ha saying "all of them" is a delightfully biting, original and witty take, we get it)
Holly Green69any of the un-frosted ones because wtf what is the point of that
Occam’s Shaving Cream II45S’mores may not have been the worst, but it’s the most disappointing relative to its potential
Questionable Taste Hours25Hot take: I don't like the chocolate ones. The fakey chocolate is gross to me. I was psyched as a kid to try the Timon and Pumbaa ones with the bug sprinkles and I was SO disappointed when I actually bit into them.
Myrna: Queer! 🌈15I sincerely don’t get why unfrosted strawberry exists. 😅
James Kalyn15Fine I’ll be the one standing up for unfrosted Pop Tarts. I don’t like the texture of the frosting.
Susan (George) Schorn14The Girl Scout Thin Mint variety was really disappointing.
L Chupacabra: The Pope Of Chili Town9The Girl Scouts flavors were bad.
Highly throwable shrimp9this was even worse than the root beer one somehow
xX_RazorbladeRawrbie_xX | 👾 🐧 | Scenecore Superhero PNGTuber!9HONESTLY? I don't recall ever trying them, but the Crush Soda ones seem terrible on principle.
Lydia Diane8...i can't think of a pop tart flavor i ever had that was bad.
When there are 30 flavors, but your mom only buys the one she likes. That flavor.
※ ℬℯ𝓉𝒽 ※7Any one that had chocolate in it. I don't like the kind of chocolate they use for them. Just give me a Frosted Cherry or a Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon, and we're good.
Jean Casey Thompson7Whatever the hell this was supposed to be
Veronica6Brown sugar. Much too sweet
Meatyguy6The mystery "everything bagel" ones from a few years ago. Absolutely disGUSTANG
💿🐬Anthonia Loud💙🌐 (🎂July 2nd🎂)6The Crush Orange Flavor Pop-Tart, I Don't Like It.
Hollie5I don’t have an answer to this one, but I would like to say that my mother used to a) cut mine into bite-sized pieces, and b) smother them in butter (these were the chocolate ones). Why did she do that??
PUNKTACTYX5there's this chocolate chip pancake one that i assume was a recent release... made me wonder if i even liked pancakes that much.
Sarah Walsh5The frickin unfrosted ones. Any of them.
Dread Pirate Sex Badger4I have a universal rule of never eating anything claiming to be cherry flavoured. Except cherries.
Evirus4I've never had a bad Pop Tart, but I've hardly had them all.
Andrew Nelson4One of the plain ones probably, strawberry? They just kind of sad without frosting, but otherwise they’re generally decent to great.
Benjamin Franklinstein4I got a box of these from the markdown rack at my local Ralphs. I think it set me back about two bucks. It was koyaanisqatsi, corrupt, out of balance.
gcp4S’mores. Still have a nostalgic weakness for strawberry and frosted strawberry, but those might be the only two I like.
MoralOrelHershiser3I really hate the lemon blueberry crumble as far as contemporary flavors go And, as always, bring back unfrosted peanut butter you cowards @kellogs
Guy Incognito3Strawberry - there - I said it.
Carlos Yu3was there a chocolate fudge one or has my brain turned into an LLM? no, they're a flavor. maybe I just had a bad batch.
Chad Ecto One3HAHAHA ALL OF THEM HAHAHAHAHAHA GET IT ITS FUNNY AND ORIGINAL HAAHA
z0phn.bsky.social3Any off brand unfrosted one sucked. The best was Frosted Dutch Apple.
⊹₊♛₊⊹𝕶𝖆𝖙 𝕶𝖍𝖗𝖔𝖓𝖎𝖈⊹₊♛₊⊹3smores is fucking disgusting and i LOVE marshmallow
T. Filson Rogers2All I know is that nobody can say anything negative about blueberry whatever. I dare you
Jack★2I am usually not adventurous with pop tarts bc there's a lot of misses but every and any wild berry anything has always been so BAD and they keep repackaging it That and the s'mores flavor
darkest timeline2I once, accidentally, has s'mores flavor. (I don't much care for marshmallow)
Korey2Wildberry if I recall correctly
Batsy Cline (she/her) 🦇📚2Chocolate chip cookie dough. Pregnant me thought they sounded amazing. Pregnant me threw them up.
Scooter2red velvet (cookies n creme sucks too)
Brian Kane2Never liked any of the chocolate-flavored ones.
greenlightening.bsky.social2I feel like I will never find the answer bc any time I reach for a pop tart (seldom), I can’t resist buying s’mores. I know at that point it’s just dessert, but I can’t help it.
Thomas2We got a chocolate chip pancake one that was criminal
Sisko's Baseball2That recent Birthday Cake one was awful.
Holly Green2oh also I had a chocolate orange one from the UK that I was expecting a lot out of, but it was disappointingly mild
The Ghost of Nihl L'Amas2I haven't had too many so I can't drag out anything interesting, but I think the cherry was bad.
Krijthebold2When I was a kid I loved the brown sugar ones but at some point something switched in my tastes and now they're just way too sweet.
Neil Blackman2If they make any Pop-Tart flavor, i'm gonna be the one sucker who is gonna like it. It's a curse.
⚙️ Euphrates ⚙️2The "Mystery Flavored" ones that were everything bagel flavored. Savory Pop-Tarts are gross on principle but that was particularly bad
