Study: School phone bans linked to gradual gains in test scores
Illinois enacted a bell-to-bell cellphone policy in our classrooms so our kids can focus on what really matters. Research shows positive results — schools with bans are seeing improvements in test scores.
This is common sense and should have been instituted as soon as kids started carrying cell phones.
Do we have exceptions for kids with medical needs (e.g. blood sugar monitors) that are now all connected to smart phone apps? While I agree that they need to focus on their studies, I also need to know that we aren't being draconian about this.
This is a good use of government. Not like republican corruption.
It remains funny to me that the group of people most aggressively opposed to this obviously good policy are a bunch of social media addicts in their 30s and 40s who have no dog in this fight beyond finding the idea of having to put their phones down intolerable.
We take education seriously here in Illinois—that means getting rid of distractions in the classroom.
In Japan elementary and junior high student cannot bring cellphones into school at all. It's so weird to think this isn't universal.
“Schools with strict bans —requiring students to lock their phones in pouches all school day — saw math and reading scores improve as if students had an additional week or two of school a year, the study found. It was published Tuesday by the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard.”
“In reading, the bans also cut down on sliding backward — fewer students had their scores decrease over the year. Researchers say that reading seems to be more affected by screen use because it requires sustained focus, and because screens often displace time spent reading.”
Well, of course they are improving. Allowing phones in classrooms is so obviously stupid and counter-productive to learning.....why did it take so long to figure this out? Were the people who were meant to figure it out on their phones all the time?
para surpresa de absolutamente ninguém, proibir uso de celular na escola melhorou o desempenho dos alunos
I once had my discman taken away by the principal for a month because he saw me listening to it at lunch. That was excessive as hell, but I don't know how the current level of permissiveness came into being. I'm sure moron parents are the biggest factor.
Proíbe bet a vida melhora Proíbe celular a vida melhora O dia em que proibirem IA e bilionário a gente voa.
The real stunning thing about the statewide Michigan ban that was put in place this year. There's been like zero fight over it year-to-year. I was expecting tooth and nail disagreement, but it's not been an issue at all. I'm stunned.
This is literally what we, the student body, proposed to Richmond County, GA circa 2011. But instead we got: 1. First offense, phone is confiscated for 30 days. 2. Second offense, phone is confiscated for 60 days. 3. Third offense, phone is donated to charity.
Questions I have Did these schools also ban laptop learning as many schools now hand kids a laptop or tablet for homework Are children allowed to grab their phone during a free period What, if any, correlating factors did the study look into for a school doing a such a ban
It is incredible what a difference the phone ban has made in my kids' schools.
Cool. Now have them start at a human hour.
taking a victory lap on this around the people who cried that they had to have phone every single moment in case of imminent death
Há uns 3 anos o que se ouvia em TODO evento de educação era que a escola tinha que se adaptar ao celular, que era inevitável que o celular estivesse na escola, que era RETRÓGRADO por parte da escola não aceitar o celular Aí proibiu e melhorou E hoje se fala A MESMÍSSIMA COISA sobre IA
The study showed gains in both math and reading, for students at all levels of achievement. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/17/u...
It turns out maybe some of the answer* actually is phones. *to lots of questions, frankly
TAH DAH! (And it’s great to see)
My favorite part of this subject matter is how people who spend their entire day online and posting are convinced that putting your phone down can’t be good for you and the studies must be wrong.
pour one out for Taylor Lorenz
Latest issue of No Shit Monthly is out
All indicators seem to be showing that if you remove tech from schools, it makes learning easier. Humans most effectively learn by watching an older human show them how to be. There's no way around that. The tech, in its many forms, is almost always a distraction. #EduSky
I think you need to take phones away from time to time because you have to be able to let your phone sit on your desk without picking it up, and it takes time to learn how to do that.
wont somebody think of the test scores
Teenage me would feel so betrayed, but honestly it just has to be done You can’t talk to any of your friends who became teachers for more than 5 minutes without coming to this conclusion
this is extremely useful and heartening data, and if you think otherwise i'm glad you don't work in education because i'm certain you don't.
Now do the Chromebooks. My kid got detention for working on his website with friends during lunch. Lunch is screen free. Classes are on machines. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/17/u...
Me and my husband both come from tech backgrounds. My kid loves to code. We aren’t luddites. We also tell him he has to follow the rules — or he gets detention. But the way screens are used in schools is broken at this point.
When my kids school district switched to handing them out as needed during class and it eliminated tons of screen time bc the teachers didn’t want to take class time up handing them out and collecting them. No phones has also been a great policy.
the chromebooks are the wooooooorst
I hope this gets further along before my youngest starts teaching next year...
“The annual gains reversed about half the annual loss that an average student experienced in the years leading up to the pandemic.“ How many stories have we been sold about test score declines? We — and our students — were staring in the main answer’s face.
Now, imagine if they spent less time on school-sanctioned and -provided devices.
And of course they blamed teachers for the decline, because they were too busy listening to the billionaires pushing more tech in schools.
I am not an educator, but this seemed very obvious to me. Learning and critical thinking are more difficult with the constant distractions of a mobile phone.