White Sox Sign Dustin May to Three-Year Deal
I've been burnt too many times by Dustin May. No, ERA is not a good predictor of future value, yes, his stuff always looks good, yes, he'll help a CHW pitching staff that was desperate for innings, but I'm not getting sucked into this one again.
The AAV doesn’t seem that out of line, the three years does
I think 3/$50M is a perfectly cromulent contract for him. It's not a huge outlay on an AAV basis, it doesn't lock them into a very long-term sunk cost if he goes belly-up, and it's still potentially moveable if it comes to that.
Yeah, this is wise. BUT. I say from experience that at some point early on he’s gonna throw a wormhole two-seamer that makes you forget your own last name. (And his many many vulnerabilities and frailties up to and including salad.)
I fuckin bet Dustin May agreed to that contract, holy crap. The White Sox fixed (ish) the one Jordan Hicks, so now they're going out and collecting all the Jordan Hickses
Betting your pitching lab is better than the Brewers is certainly a choice.
Once they collect all six, they can snap their fingers and erase all the hitters with a wOBA of .325 or better on fastballs
The first nine words of this reaction are tremendous.
It's wild, but isn't $17.5m / AAV about the going rate for a depth starter in this market?
My biggest worry with the Sox surprising success last year is that they're learning the wrong lesson. We saw it at the trade deadline that they now seem to believe that they can "fix" everyone. And it's way cheaper to acquire bad players in the hope of them improving than it is acquire good ones.
2025 mets type of hubris
Sometimes being a baseball fan in November means talking about Dustin May
Talking about FA signings of players we don’t care about going to teams we don’t root for is a part of the baseball fan social contract. We all agreed to this. It's who we are.
Hopefully in December we aren't stuck just remembering Steve Christmas. No cap, no lockout, it's all Manfred's fault.
Dustin May was fine in contributing to a World Series run, but I will never forget him trotting into G2 of the NLCS. The *groan* from the crowd when the bullpen door opened is something I've never heard before. Combo of quickly identifiable looks and recent performance, I imagine.
Dude wasn't amazing, but he was fine. He got us outs in our magical year. I thank him for his service and wish him well.
He didn't have a great run and still managed a deal worth $52.5. He got the Brewers adjacent bonus either way
I wasn't groaning. I was yelling "Boooo-urns".
We heard that plenty of times, esp. IIRC in the 2010's. Trevor Hoffman trying to get that 600th save, other relievers who were inconsistent (Axeford?); you didn't know if they'd preserve the lead or not. IIRC, of course.
Dustin May to sign a 3-year, just north of $50M deal with the White Sox, per Robert Murray.
the money is fine, as long as you never expect Dustin May to be anything more than Fine then this is a good signing. the problem comes when people convince themselves Dustin May is secretly really good.
I support this deal, but I'm also a Twins fan
Edwin Jackson would have been a very rich man if he played today. Sure, the Brewers and Dodgers couldn’t make all of Mays gaudy metrics work…but what if we could
It's a sign of how ludicrously diluted the pitching market is that an injury prone sub-.500 pitcher with an ERA substantially above the league average is signing deals at $18m a year.
Thank god, this seemed like an inevitable giant Ross Atkins overpay
big move to go from having no good starting pitchers to still having no good starting pitchers
FanGraphs and MLBTR had May at 2/30, so he beats their AAV estimate and gets an extra year. Tim Britton had 2/36, so he was right (maybe slightly over) on the AAV, but also didn't predict a third year. I get it because of the upside, and the Sox need some upside.