Skip to content

BBC interviews West Bank settler who justifies attacks on Palestinians

newsAug 1, 202628857

On a BBC visit to the Havat Gilad outpost in the occupied West Bank, resident Yehuda Shimon, a lawyer who represents Israelis arrested for violence against Palestinians, told the reporter that last weekend's settler attacks were justified as revenge for the killing of the outpost's security guard. Shimon said, "I think now, after they killed one Israeli, we need to kill all the people in Tal and Sarra, even Jit and Farata," and added, "No, millions. One Jewish life, it's 10 million [Palestinians]," refusing to deny the racism when challenged and saying the Bible gives Jews the right to the land. The BBC reported the interview came days after a confrontation in the village of Tal left four Palestinians and an Israeli soldier dead, and after Havat Gilad residents staged attacks on nearby Palestinian villages. Havat Gilad is an unauthorised outpost established more than 20 years ago that Peace Now says sits partly on land privately owned by Palestinians, and Israel has previously said it would legalise the outpost. The BBC noted it is rare for international media to gain access to such outposts and that many Israelis reject the extreme views expressed. The interview illustrates how settler expansion, claims of divine entitlement, and impunity for violence are intertwined in recent rises in attacks on Palestinians in the West Bank.

Patrick "Inverted Vibe Curve" Blanchfield
@patblanchfield.bsky.social

"No," he said, "millions. One Jewish life, it's 10 million [Palestinians]." Challenged on the racism of his statement, he did not deny it. "Yes, I know," he replied. "But this is the truth, because God chose us [and] because of this you are jealous." This man is a lawyer. www.bbc.com/news/article...

20845d ago
post malone ergo propter malone
@proptermalone.bsky.social

tbf to them they were reacting to an *insanely* racist statement by a West Bank settler in which he described himself as one of the chosen people, this wasn’t out of nowhere, but like

22544d ago
Mikhail Gorbaechev56

The meaning of "chosenness" is a significant site of discourse in Judaism!

Keith41

feels like so much of remaining sane in modern discourse is successfully being able to understand that a nut-picked exemplar is not, in fact, always representative of a sometimes staggeringly broad category. That kernels of truth can be true and also still kernels.

whetstone23

that settler statement stuck out to me because i’m pretty sure it’s the first time i’ve ever seen a *jew* say that’s what being the chosen people is about in the wild i always hear it as basically “chosen to obey more rules than everyone else”

eli10

Yeah see, Kahanists do talk like this, and I have no problem describing them that way. As they understand it, yeah, it’s a terrible fucking brainworm that makes them worse people. It’s important to qualify as such ofc; per usual the fringe does nobody any favors

The Birds The Turtles and The Bees10

There is, for sure, a Jewish type of asshole that is quite distinctive in their assholeitude, but the antisemitic mistake is thinking the Jewish part is the important bit. (Also, if you aren't Jewish you probably aren't as good at identifying this subclass as you think you are.)

andrewtheblueskier8

For the record I do read about this stuff sometimes and I've never ever seen someone say /this/ as he's said it in that exact interview. It just /isn't/ mainstream Judaism in Israel or Diaspora to think of it like this, even among Religious Zionists -- he's cooked his mind from the work of killing

1 source