Skip to content

Where the Red Fern Grows remembered as a traumatic childhood read

booksApr 30, 202618411

Readers and teachers remember the 1961 novel Where the Red Fern Grows as a traumatic childhood read, pointing to the deaths of its hunting dogs and mandatory classroom screenings of the 1974 film adaptation. Accounts describe 11- and 12-year-olds sobbing through both the book and movie, and some teachers say they reluctantly assigned it while others now remove it from middle school curricula. Schools are rethinking whether to assign Where the Red Fern Grows as educators weigh its lessons about loss and coming of age against the emotional distress it can cause preteens.

Kingfisher & Wombat
@tkingfisher.com

Honorable Mentions: A Farewell to Arms (blegh) and, much earlier, Where The Red Fern Grows. I think subjecting children to multiple “your dog must die so you can become a man!” books is borderline criminal.

2031h ago
antifa annie9

Red Fern is a core memory…a traumatic one.

Tom6

Junior high teachers needing books that are short enough to fit in a couple week unit, considered classic enough that there's lesson plans already available, and cheap enough to get classroom copies for everyone narrows the selection to some real bummers. My nemesis was A Separate Peace

Amanda Valentine5

I had to teach Where the Red Fern Grows and I hated it. So I approached it that way - told the kids I hated it but we had to do this. The argumentative kids pushed back by telling me what was good about it. I suspect that maybe we should be teaching things we hate.

Rivikah5

Oh. The Red Pony. I had apparently blocked that from my memory entirely.

Ankarah5

What IS it with all the "young reader" books where dogs have to die?!?! I mean I'm sure there're only a handful but as a kid it seemed like there was a freakish fixation some authors had on killing off pets.

Sublitotic4

The Scarlet Letter. Its main value was in making everything else seem much more interesting. Even can labels.

Fiddler Meg4

The only reason I was able to read The Twisted Ones was because everyone was reassuring everyone else that nothing bad happens to the dog.

Megan Macmanus2

Oh, A Farewell to Arms almost ruined my relationship with my dad, who at that time i thought could do no wrong! I came home ranting about the misogynistic horror dubbed a Romance, and he was like, That's the most romantic book ever. It's my favorite. Something died that day. 😂

Sharrow 🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️🇮🇪🦄💙📚🎃2

Of mice and men, esp when the pupils are autistic.

Unconnie Valley2

A Day No Pigs Would Die is somewhere on the list