White House paper proposes more AI funding, less for universities
A key element of post-WW2 US science policy was recognizing science had become too "big" for individual tinkerers on personal funding, we needed to support institutions, labs, programs. But 'genius tinkerer' is exactly what these bros imagine, part of hating the "professional-managerial class"
Surely, 1000 physicists each working alone with 27 meters of collider tube can produce more than funding a big bureaucratic LHC and working together
This here 👇👇👇 It was a strategic decision that led to building serious and lasting and innovative scientific institutions.
The Trump administration wants to try to give funding to individual researchers at universities instead of routing funds through institutions. I read this as an effort to eliminate indirect costs after the administration lost that battle in court last year. Gift link.
Not to mention the grafting opportunities
So… then universities have to charge rent to use their facilities? The researcher has to do the work to get their assistants paid? Sounds like more bureaucracy, not less, in the hands of someone who probably really doesn’t want to do it.
First up. Criticism of peer review and implementation of "agile" new funding organizational structures. 3/9
Next, AI, quantum computing, fusion, manned space missions, and semiconductor technology. 4/9
Um, don't we already fund individual scientists? Maybe they want to go back to a system of random people in their home laboratories? Not sure you'll get quantum AI fusion on the moon that way though...
UW–Madison will receive 5 Phase I Genesis Mission awards from the Department of Energy addressing urgent energy, scientific, and engineering challenges with AI and advanced computing. @uwmadison.bsky.social earned more awards than any other public university in the US. news.wisc.edu/5-projects-a...
Proud of UW-Madison and the Madison area's showing with Genesis (even though my proposal wasn't selected). Happy to say that the Data Science Institute is supporting some of the successful proposals.
Nice showing at UW-Madison, though given what I know about the number of applications, the overall success rate remains.. not very high!